Humanism and reasoning versus cookbook medicine

Soledad Delgado
 

From "criaderas" to "soleras"

At the onset of autumn, my land fills with the smell of must. Freshly extracted from the pressed grape, it ferments and then passes to American oak barrels for ageing. The containers are stacked at three levels. From the lower one, the "solera", a third of its content is extracted for consumption. That part is filled with wine from the intermediate level, the first “criadera", and the same happens with this one, which receives wine from the upper level, the second “criadera". It's the one who receives the fresh must, full of life and potential. This wine, still young, is mixed during its ageing with matured wine, from which it takes some characteristics and to which it gives back the freshness of new aromas and flavours. The two wines are enriching each other, sheltered by the flower veil that promotes biological ageing. 

Tolerate uncertainty: the pending revolution

Arabella Simpkin (Harvard Medical School) and Richard Schwartzstein (Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center) have published "Tolerating Uncertainty - The Next Medical Revolution?", An article that inspired me to continue with the speech I began in "Against the medicine of manual ", following the reading of “When doctors don’t listen” by Leana Wen and Joshua Kosowsky.

"Although physicians," the authors say, "know that the uncertainty lies in clinical work, the current culture of medicine pushes them to give unequivocal answers, often impossible or even implausible yes/no answers, essential for labelling codes, which pretend, clumsily, to pick up narratives full of nuances, coming from people full of doubts or even forgetful. "

Against cookbook medicine

"How can modern medicine be so dehumanized?" is a question posed by Dr. Leana Wen and Dr. Joshua Kosowsky in “When doctors don’t listen”. According to them, with a few exceptions, the practice of medicine is subjugated by the dictatorship of guidelines, algorithms, codes, protocols and rules. "Cookbook medicine" they call it. Everyone is aware that many requested tests are unnecessary and that many people are subjected to anxiety induced by the prescribed manual diagnostic processes to rule out infrequent pathologies. The theory of the book is based on the fact that the process to arrive at a diagnosis is complex, requires an interview in which the patient can frankly express the story of what is happening to him, a physical examination according to the hypotheses that arise and a clinical reasoning participated by the patient himself; all this, very far from a manual practice.

Can health community work be of any use?

Great @nytimes article on need for community health workers #CHWs featuring my colleague @prabhjotsinghNY... http://t.co/wShbXqQl46

— Leana Wen, M.D. (@DrLeanaWen) 29 agost, 2014

Dr. Leana Wen, the chosen tweet author and author of the book "When doctors don’t listen", warns her followers that Tina Rosenberg has published an article in the New York Times about what Community Health Workers in the US do. After reading Rosenberg’s article, I thought that this tweet was not a good choice for our readers, as the American reality is a lot different from ours (in Spain). They have a much messier model and therefore they need low cost professionals who can lend a helping hand; in short, poorly paid quasi-volunteers working for charities helping the management of issues such as medication and habits of people living in poverty.